Dodgers Recap: Phils Take Extra-Inning Thriller in October Preview

CHAVEZ RAVINE — Dodger Stadium had October energy on Monday night—a roaring crowd of 43,602, stars on both sides trading haymakers, momentum swinging inning to inning. In the end, the Phillies slipped out with a 6–5 win in 10, clinching the NL East on the Dodger Stadium turf and dealing the Dodgers’ first-round bye hopes a tough blow. It was a thriller, but also a reminder: in games with playoff intensity, the little things decide everything.

The night started with a gut punch and then turned into an Emmet Sheehan showcase. Anthony Banda recorded one out and surrendered a laser to Kyle Schwarber—his 53rd—before Dave Roberts handed the ball to Sheehan. From there, the right-hander was brilliant, giving the Dodgers exactly what they needed: 5.2 innings of one-hit, one-run ball with seven strikeouts. He mowed through the heart of the Philly order in the third, quieted traffic in the fourth and sixth, and left to a deserved ovation in the seventh after a ground-rule double opened the frame. The line says one earned run; the eye test says he kept the Dodgers afloat. The relief pitching before and after him, not so much.

The Dodgers scratched first with smart baseball. Andy Pages ripped a leadoff double in the third, Chuckie Robinson bunted him to third, and Mookie Betts lifted a sac fly to tie the game 1–1. Max Muncy then put L.A. ahead with a solo shot in the fifth, his 18th, and the Dodgers played add-on later in the inning: Robinson reached, Shohei Ohtani smoked a double to right, and Betts delivered another sac fly for a 3–1 edge. It wasn’t an avalanche, but it was opportunistic—manufacturing runs against Ranger Suárez while Sheehan kept a lid on the Phillies.

Then came the seesaw. After Otto Kemp’s ground-rule double chased Sheehan to start the seventh, Jack Dreyer entered and the game turned instantly. A Bryson Stott RBI single cut the lead to 3–2, and Weston Wilson followed with a two-run blast to center to flip it 4–3, Phillies. The Dodgers, to their credit, punched right back in the bottom half. Wearing No. 21 in honor of his Roberto Clemente Award nomination, Betts unloaded on an Orion Kerkering pitch and sent it into the left-center seats to tie it 4–4. Big star, big moment, big number. Dodger Stadium shook.

The eighth belonged to Bryce Harper by inches. Alex Vesia didn’t throw a cookie—this wasn’t a hanger begging to be punished—but Harper tomahawked a letter-high heater and muscled it out to center for a 5–4 Phillies lead. That’s what MVPs do: turn good pitches into bad outcomes. L.A. again refused to fold. Johan Duran hadn’t allowed a homer since July, but the rookie Pages ambushed him in the ninth, launching a game-tying solo shot to left for his 25th. From the Schwarber opener to the Betts equalizer to the Harper answer to the Pages jolt—this was heavyweight stuff, back and forth, all night.

Extras came down to those little things that win postseason games. With the automatic runner at second, Harrison Bader stole third, Harper drew an intentional walk, and J.T. Realmuto did exactly what the situation demanded: a clean sac fly to right for a 6–5 Phillies lead. In the bottom half, the Dodgers executed the first step—Betts, the ghost runner, moved to third on a Ben Rortvedt grounder—and then stalled. Freddie Freeman was intentionally walked, Alex Call worked a walk to load the bases, but a pop-up from Miguel Rojas and a Max Muncy grounder to first ended it. The Phillies cashed their small margin; the Dodgers came up one swing short.

A few numbers underline the story. The Dodgers went 0-for-8 with runners in scoring position and stranded nine. They got three RBIs from Betts (two sac flies and that massive seventh-inning homer) and the late heroics from Pages. Ohtani reached three times, including a ringing double, and stole his 19th. But the relief ledger around Sheehan was costly: Dreyer wore the blown save on the Wilson homer, Vesia yielded Harper’s go-ahead shot, and Blake Treinen—tasked with keeping the 10th at 0—saw the clinching run score on that Realmuto sac fly. Tanner Scott was a bright spot with a clean ninth and two strikeouts, but the pen as a whole gave up three homers and the decisive extra-inning run.

Context matters, too. With the loss, the Phillies clinched the NL East, and while the Dodgers remain atop the NL West, their path to a first-round bye narrowed considerably. There’s still time and enough talent to make a push, but every missed RISP chance and every poorly timed mistake stretches the road a little longer. The silver lining is obvious: if this is the caliber of baseball waiting in October, the Dodgers proved they can trade blows with anyone. They fought back three separate times, got star turns from Betts and a rookie spark from Pages, and watched Sheehan look every bit like a playoff weapon.

In the end, it was the smallest margins—the sac fly they allowed, the sac flys they got, and the one knock they couldn’t find with a runner at third and one out—that separated a celebration on the field from a clinch in the visitors’ clubhouse. Playoff atmosphere? Absolutely. Playoff lesson? Definitely. Convert the little things, and the big moments belong to you. Tonight, they belonged to Philadelphia.

Have you subscribed to the Bleed Los Podcast YouTube channel? Be sure to ring the notification bell to watch player interviews, participate in shows & promotions, and stay up to date on all Dodgers news and rumors!